Tonya And Nancy
Book and Lyrics by Elizabeth Searle
Music by Michael Teoli
Directed by Jon Martinez
Produced by Underscore Theatre Company and Harborside Films
November 25th to December 30th, 2016 at Theater Wit

The Olympics, 1994. Tonya Harding has hardly had the chance to dream past her father’s truck. Nancy Kerrigan has it all–supportive family, affluent background, beauty and effortless grace. Enter Tonya’s no-account boyfriend Jeff Gillooly, who has a plan to “help” Tonya win. What will happen when each skater has only three and a half minutes to be perfect?
Press and Awards
"Tonya And Nancy lands a triple axel!...an overall perfect score...skates the line between drama and comedy." - Alyssa Dyksterhouse, Perform.ink
"Funny... quite profound... Amanda Horvath and Courtney Mack are excellent." - Chris Jones, The Chicago Tribune
"Top 5 musicals of 2016!" - Newcity Stage
"Just as drama-packed as the real thing!" - People.com
"Delicious...driving energy...a stroke of brilliance" - Hedy Weiss, The Chicago Sun-Times
2017 Jeff Award Winner: Veronica Garza, Non-Equity Acress in a Supporting Role - Musical
2017 Jeff Award Nominee: Amanda Horvath, Non-Equity Actress in a Principal Role - Musical
![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
---|---|---|---|
![]() | ![]() | ![]() | ![]() |
Cast & Creatives
Tonya Harding - Amanda Horvath
Nancy Kerrigan - Courtney Mack
Tonya/Nancy's Mom - Veronica Garza
Jeff Gillooly - Justin Adair
Chase/Kristi Yamaguchi - Mari Uchida
Titania/Surya Bonalay - Tyler Symonè Franklin
Andrew/Shawn Echardt - Vasily Deris
Hedi/Oksana Baiul - Genevieve Perrino
Dewayne/Shane Stant - Graham Hawley
Ryan/Skater Fan - Caleb Baze
Swing (Titania, Hedi, Chase) - Mollyann Nunn
Swing (Andrew, Dewayne, Ryan) - Jonas Davidow
Director/Choreographer - Jon Martinez
Music Director - Aaron Benham
Stage Manager - Michael Starcher
Associate Director - Adrian Azevedo
Associate Choreographer - Joseph Kuchey
Lighting Designer - Maya Fein
Set Designer - Jimmy Jagos
Costume Designer - Virginia Varland
Artistic Director - Alex Higgen-Houser
Executive Director - Laura Stratford
Production Director - Geoff Bleeker